Continuing what I started last week. I grew up a Yankees fan in the 90's, and they gave me the benefit of 4 championships. Their resurgence brought them back into the national spotlight, and by 2000, the guys who took pitches and didn't put up gaudy numbers were now All-Stars. In the era of McGuire/Sosa/Bonds juicing and boosting, my New York Yankees sent most of their team to the All-Star Game. There were two problems though, both related.
One: The Core of the Yankees teams was getting older. Only Derek Jeter, Jorge Posada, Bernie Williams, Andy Pettite and Mariano Rivera were under age 30 by 2000. Tino, Brosius, Paulie... they were getting older. By 2001, they were headed out, either into retirement or other teams.
Two: George M. Steinbrenner III, the owner of the New York Yankees, loves power. Power pitching, power hitting.He was never happy that the championship teams didn't have a slugger. That's why he got Darryl, why he got Irabu, and Clemens. He wanted pitchers throwing gas and hitters swatting 400 ft. moonshots.
Enter the 21st century. Enter the end of my New York Yankees.
To be fair, the team has been successful, but the team I had grown to love was barely a remnant. Looking back at the additions, you can see positives and negatives:
2002:
David Wells: Known winner, but aging retread. Ended up costing us the 2003 World Series with injury.
Jason Giambi: Great power hitter, but steroid offender and he became a pull hitter who hit for low average, as opposed to the .300 - 40 - 120 guy he was in his MVP year
Rondell White: Had nothing left
Robin Ventura: Veteran in the twilight of his career.
Jeff Weaver: Really? Need I say more.
SEASON ANALYSIS: They were beat by a younger, more athletic Angels team. They really should have focused on youth and defense.
2003: Jose Contreras: Gave us one good season. Wasn't as good as El Duque
Hideki Matsui: Declining health has sapped any potential from Matsui. Had some good years, but nothing spectacular.
SEASON ANALYSIS: Not enough pitching. Beginning of the end, as the team brought in bad pitchers and focused on getting sluggers who don't field well.
2004: Alex Rodriguez: The antithesis of the Yankee way of the 90's: selfish, me-first, high maintenece. I don't hate Alex, but I wasn't please when we got him. I would've preferred the Angels' Chone Figgins or someone else.
Gary Sheffield: Another power guy who was a liability on the field. I didn't hate Gary, in fact I thought he was a good player, but with Giambi and Matsui, the defense of the team stank to high heaven.
Javier Vasquez: I don't think he got a fair chance to succeed. One season does not a career make. Too bad.
Kevin Brown: I remember the Yankees destroying him in the World Series in 1998... why would you get someone you beat up on?
Kenny Lofton: Bernie was declining, but Kenny wasn't an amazing player either.
SEASON ANALYSIS: They were close to beating the Sox, but you can tell this team was more mercenary than warrior. The team lacked heart, chemistry and the ability to bounce back.
2005: Randy Johnson: Ultimate proof about players needing the ability to handle New York.
Carl Pavano: Has no tolerance for pain. Didn't use his head. Worst free-agent signing in recent Yankees history.
Jaret Wright: Was good early in career. Not so good with Yankees. Injuries also factor. Bad deal.
SEASON ANALYSIS: Another wipeout by the Angels. Again, youth and defense serves the Angels well.
2006: Johnny Damon: First legit lead-off hitter for the Yanks since Knoblauch. Not a bad addition, but also a player on the decline defensively.
Kyle Farnsworth: Fireballer who did little to nothing.
Cory Lidle: Had an ok season, followed by a horrible, fatal accident. RIP Cory. What else can I say? I refuse to talk bad about someone who died before he was supposed to.
Bobby Abreu: Great fantasy player, not so great right fielder. Seems to be doing well in Anahein, good for him.
SEASON ANALYSIS: Too reliant on the long ball still. Pitchers didn't perform.
2007: Kei Igawa: the 2nd worst free-agent signing in recent Yankees history.
Andy Pettite: He should never have left pinstripes.
Roger Clemens: Aging legend in decline. Also steroids user. Blargh.
SEASON ANALYSIS: Maybe if Torre stopped the game for Joba, they woulda beat the Indians. I doubt it. Starting to make the turn around.
2008: Re-sign A-Rod: As much as people don't like him, his production is useful. Despite the conception that he only produces when behind big or up big, he was huge in 2007.
Joe Girardi: Replacing beloved Joe Torre, got off to rocky start. Team is still like previous teams, so he didn't have much to work with.
SEASON ANALYSIS: Girardi's first year as manager was ok, not spectacular. The empahsis on young pitching started to show, as well as some youth in the field, with Melky Cabrera and Brett Gardner.
The overall theme is that Steinbrenner's desire to get sluggers and pitchers who didn't necessarily fit into the Yankees enviornment, has changed the team fundamentally. Financially, the team grew. On the field, the team still won more than it lost, but it lost the most important part of the championship Yankees.
It lost it's soul.
For the final part, I'm going to take a look at this season, the New Yankee Stadium, and what I think of the future of the organization that I love.